🏫Learn How I Run Math Groups

Must Do May Do for Math: Run Small Groups Without Rotations

Are you tired of math rotations that never quite work the way you planned?

You know the ones. Group A finishes their center in eight minutes and starts wandering. The timer goes off right when you are in the middle of explaining something important. Someone always seems to be in the wrong spot.

The worst part for me was when I realized my groupings had students grouped together that had NO BUSINESS being grouped together. And they were together, traveling around the room, misbehaving, day after day.

I decided nothing was being accomplished this way. It was starting to look like a waste of time in the school day, but my school required small group math time, so I had to do something different.

Instead, I started experimenting with using a Must Do May Do system for math. Students stayed at their seats and worked through a short list of tasks. I pulled groups to my table whenever I was ready. No bells. No set rotation times. No one walking around the room every fifteen minutes.

The realization I had was surprising. It was so simple and that’s why it worked better!

What is a Must Do May Do system for math?

A Must Do is something students are expected to finish during the math block. A May Do is something they can choose once their Must Dos are done.

That is it.

The big difference from traditional rotations is that students do not move from station to station on a timer. They work at their own pace at their seats (or any open desk or seating). You call the students you want to your table when you are ready for them.

You can keep a group for as long as you need. You can send them back early. You can even pull the same students more than once if they need it. The rest of the class keeps working.

How it works during your math block

Here is the basic flow.

You start with a short whole-group mini-lesson or warm-up if you want one.

Then students begin their Must Do list at their seats.

While they work, you pull the students you need for small group instruction. These groups can change based on the skill you are teaching that day. They do not have to stay the same all week.

When you finish with a group, you send them back to their seats and call the next group.

Students who finish their Must Dos move on to May Dos.

The rest of the class is not waiting for a timer or trying to figure out where to go next. They already know what to do.

What to put on the Must Do list

Keep the Must Do list short. Two or three things is usually enough.

Good options include:

  • Today’s independent practice page
  • A problem of the day or short review problem
  • Gluing an interactive notebook page into math notebooks (not necessarily working on it–just getting it ready!)
  • Fluency practice (dry erase practice, flash cards, or a program like XtraMath)

These tasks reinforce what you just taught and can be done independently once students know the routine.

If you use my Guided Math units, each day already includes a practice page that lines up with the lesson. That practice page becomes an easy Must Do. You do not have to create something new every day.

Make sure your must do list is not too long and intimidating or students will not make their way through it.

This is an example must do may do list. Keep it simple!

example must do may do poster

What to put on the May Do list

May Dos should be things students actually want to do. If the choices are boring, they will not work hard to finish their Must Dos.

Options that work well:

  • The day’s center activity
  • Math games
  • Digital practice
  • Extension activities (foldable interactive notebook pages, dice games, board games, etc.)
  • Centers you have already introduced

I like having one daily center that matches the lesson. It keeps the May Do list from getting stale and gives students extra practice with the current skill.

When you introduce a new center or game, do it in a small group first. That way students already know how to do it when it shows up as a May Do.

A sample 60-minute math block

Here is one way this can look:

  • 10 minutes: whole-group mini-lesson or warm-up
  • 45–50 minutes: students work on Must Dos while you pull flexible groups
  • Students move to May Dos as they finish

You do not have to stick to exact times. If a group needs more help, keep them longer. If everyone is working well, you can pull an extra group or two.

Tips to make it run smoothly

Spend time teaching the routine at the beginning. Students need to know what independent work looks like and sounds like.

Post a simple Must Do / May Do chart where everyone can see it.

Have a clear plan for where students should sit and how they move from task to task. Is there something they need to turn in? Where do they complete their May Do activities?

Start simple. Remember–you can always add more Must Do options later once students are independent. In the beginning you want to keep it simple to get them to buy in!

If you want a day-by-day plan for teaching the routine, I have a free 10-day launch guide here: How to Launch Guided Math in 10 Days

Ready to try it?

A Must Do May Do system takes the pressure off of managing rotations. You get flexible small group time. Students stay productive. And you are not constantly watching the clock.

The year-long Guided Math bundles for grades 1–5 make this even easier. Each day includes a lesson plan, a practice page, and a center activity. Those pieces can become your Must Do and May Do without extra planning.

You can preview the bundle for your grade level here:

Start with a short Must Do list and one or two solid May Do options. Once students know the routine, the whole math block gets a lot calmer!!

Share it:
Email
Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter